Court Upholds End-User License Agreements
Ruling has substantial repercussions for digital media/software.
The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit recently ruled that End-User License Agreements (EULAs) are absolutely binding, thereby making resale, redistribution, modifications and any other terms forbidden within the agreement illegal.
The court's decision came from an appeal to the case Vernor v. Autodesk, in which Timothy Vernor sued Autodesk for repeatedly trying to shutdown his eBay business where he sold used software including AutoCAD, a program developed by Autodesk. In 2008 a federal court ruled Vernor's resale legal, but now an appeal has overturned that ruling, stating that an end-user is subject to the terms of an EULA, even if dictates that the user does not, in fact own the software, but is instead a licensee.
"We hold today that a software user is a licensee rather than an owner of a copy where the copyright owner (1) specifies that the user is granted a license; (2) significantly restricts the user’s ability to transfer the software; and (3) imposes notable use restrictions," the ruling said.
If an end-user licenses a product, they don't technically own said product and therefore are not allowed to resell it, rent it, modify it, and so forth.
The ramifications of this ruling are quite far-reaching in the digital media realm, as music services, movie purchases, and editing tools all contain EULAs that can restrict distribution rights and ownership.
The only entity that can change the amount of control software companies and their EULAs have over end-users is Congress.
Comments
comments powered by DisqusSubscribe to our Linux Newsletters
Find Linux and Open Source Jobs
Subscribe to our ADMIN Newsletters
Support Our Work
Linux Magazine content is made possible with support from readers like you. Please consider contributing when you’ve found an article to be beneficial.
![Learn More](https://www.linux-magazine.com/var/linux_magazin/storage/images/media/linux-magazine-eng-us/images/misc/learn-more/834592-1-eng-US/Learn-More_medium.png)
News
-
Canonical Offers 12-Year LTS for Open Source Docker Images
Canonical is expanding its LTS offering to reach beyond the DEB packages with a new distro-less Docker image.
-
Plasma Desktop 6.1 Released with Several Enhancements
If you're a fan of Plasma Desktop, you should be excited about this new point release.
-
SUSE Offers CentOS 7 Support with Liberty Linux Lite
SUSE's Liberty Linux support offering now includes CentOS 7, which means businesses won't be forced to migrate those servers for some time.
-
Ubuntu's App Center Finally Supports Local Installs Again
If you regularly download .deb files and would prefer a GUI method of installing, Ubuntu has your back.
-
AlmaLinux Now Supports Raspberry Pi 5
If you're looking to create with the Raspberry Pi 5 and want to use AlmaLinux as your OS, you're in luck because it's now possible.
-
Kubuntu Focus Releases New Iterations of Ir14 and Ir16 Laptops
If you're a fan of the Kubuntu Focus laptops or have been waiting for the right time to purchase one, that time might be now.
-
NixOS 24.05 Is Ready for Prime Time
The latest release of NixOS (Uakari) has arrived and offers its usual reproducible, declarative, and reliable goodness.
-
Linux Lite 7.0 Officially Released
Based on Ubuntu 24.04 and kernel 6.8, Linux Lite version 7 now offers more options than ever.
-
KaOS Linux 2024.05 Adds Bcachfs Support and More
With updates all around, KaOS Linux now includes support for the bcachefs file system.
-
TUXEDO Computers Unveils New Iteration of the Stellaris Laptop Line
The Stellaris Slim 15 is the 6th generation and includes either an AMD or Intel CPU
Slavery
... and if it is supported but legal system - shame on you! I thought slavery is illegal.
An issue of ownership
It will also be interesting to see whether or not additional companies adopt similar EULAs in the wake of this ruling. For awhile now video game companies have been dissatisfied with the used gaming market shouldered by franchises like Gamestop and soon Best Buy and Target for gouging consumers and reselling software and hardware. Simply put resold hardware does not contribute to a company's bottom line, but if these companies implement a similar EULA, they could forbid gamers from reselling purchased games.
Court Upholds End-User License Agreements
Free Market vs Indentured Commercialization
Spread the word that there is a difference between a Free Marketplace and Indentured Commercialization.
Back in the day most of our money went to purchase items from real marketplaces, Mom and Pop Stores, and buy what you get principles at work. Nowadays the clever calculus of advantage and exploitation divided by the risks of the general public getting overtly agitated enough to legislate control over the indenturetude of buyers, gets calculated into a formula for how to get the most out of others without them realizing it, and more-so than just money.
We're talking about little bits and pieces of the American Way getting eaten up without our notice. it's like a cancer. In fact, I believe the biggest threat to our Freedom and Liberty in the Future won't come from Neo-Nazis or Neo-Communists, but rather the slow erosion of what we already take for granted.. with Iron Curtain Software and Indentured Commercialization everywhere.
A not-so-free Free "Marketplace" is festering deeper and deeper into the body cavity of Free Enterprise. But if you look closely you can see the light, and its getting brighter and brighter every day. Switch to FOSS soon, or else.
Light at the end of the tunnel
EULA headaches